Andrey (azangru) wrote,
Andrey
azangru

Two absolutely unrelated thoughts about absolutely unrelated internal inconsistencies.

One is in Leslie Kean's Surviving Death. The book compiles various life-after-death-related ideas, along with evidence to support them, some of which seem to be mutually exclusive. Specifically, one is the idea of reincarnation (supported by reports of children telling presumably verifiable facts which they were unlikely to have obtained by any rational means), and the other is the idea of communication with the deceased through mediums (supported by reports of mediums giving presumably accurate information that they were unlikely to have obtained by any rational means). The inconsistency is, the idea of reincarnation contradicts the idea of continual survival of the "discarnate" (such a lovely word!) in this discarnated form that is accessible to the medium(*). The book does not attempt (at least so far as I managed to read it) to reconcile these two ideas.

The other is Andre Stalz's presentation The Decentralized Web. His thesis is that the web itself is dying because users are steadily flocking into several closed hubs, most notably Google and Facebook, and the rest of the web becomes discoverable increasingly only through these hubs. This somehow leads him to the conclusion that the web is doomed, and that one of the escape routes is a peer-to-peer decentralized web that exists in parallel to these corporate giants, according to its own laws. The inconsistency in this picture is (it seems to me) the issue of discoverability. If most of the web gets less and less discoverable due to self interest of Google and Facebook (and this is what Andre sees as a problem, because apparently if you aren't googlable then you do not exist), then it should follow that the parallel peer-to-peer portion of the internet is undiscoverable too.



*) By the way, Julie Beischel's guest chapter (which I think is to a large extent a variation of this article) is really fascinating in the sense of methodological rigor of research, even on such a woo-ey subject.
Subscribe

  • (no subject)

    Results of a survey. No idea who those guys are or how reliable their data, but I've been wondering for a while now what people mean when they say…

  • (no subject)

    I'm listening to The Ickabog, by J.K. Rowling and read, with much gusto, by Stephen Fry. What started like a nice children's tale not dissimilar from…

  • (no subject)

    From today's questions to the Prime Minister: Mr Speaker, today, millions of Uyghur people in China live in fear under a cruel regime. The BBC,…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 3 comments